Editorial 21 october 2024

Editorial 21 october 2024

editorial

Title: ​ Complicit: On India and the U.S and Canada cases

The U.S. Department of Justice’s second indictment against an Indian intelligence and paramilitary officer, in the alleged plot to kill American-Khalistani activist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, indicates another serious turn in the case that has cast a long shadow over India-U.S. ties. The indictment against Vikash Yadav was released publicly along with an arrest warrant and his listing on the FBI’s database of “most wanted” — the first time that an Indian official has been so marked out. The developments come just after a high-level Indian security delegation investigating the matter travelled to the U.S., and the U.S. State Department expressed “satisfaction” with India’s cooperation. There is cause for concern now: the second indictment that supersedes the one against jailed businessman Nikhil Gupta, repeats linkages to the Canadian case of the 2023 killing of Canadian-Khalistani activist Hardeep Nijjar. It seems no coincidence that the indictment is timed with the Canadian expulsion of Indian diplomats, sparking a diplomatic storm and also statements by the “Five Eyes” urging India to cooperate in the investigation with Canada. That these statements reek of a double standard, given that these countries have a record on transnational killings, must not stop India from upholding the law. But this surely raises questions about whether these allies are reliable as India’s closest strategic partners.

New Delhi must not delude itself and must proceed on the assumption that the cases in the U.S. and Canada are being linked by their investigating agencies. The stark difference in the Modi government’s outraged denial of the Canadian charges while providing a sympathetic ear for the American charges may prove untenable as the trial in the U.S. progresses. It is in India’s interest to clarify whether it believes Mr. Yadav was a “rogue” agent or was carrying out orders from senior officials, when he allegedly promised “2-3” contract killings a month against targeted members of the diaspora. While the External Affairs Ministry has since confirmed that he “no longer works for the government”, the indictment claims that he was employed by India’s Cabinet Secretariat, under which the R&AW is run. Whether the truth lies in incompetence or complicity, the image of the government’s intelligence and national security operations is dimmed. If the government proceeds to prosecute him or turn him over to U.S. agencies, it must also consider the impact on the morale of other operatives essaying future operations. Above all, the government must be more transparent about its policy on transnational killings. If it does not allow such operations, and it should not, then it is time for a more detailed investigation into its internal processes as well as a more realistic evaluation of its diplomatic relations.

Meaning of the word:

WordMeaningSynonymsAntonyms
IndictmentAn indictment is a formal accusation or charge of a serious crime made against a person or entity. It is usually issued by a grand jury after reviewing evidence presented by prosecutors.Accusation
Charge
Allegation Prosecution
Acquittal
Exoneration
Pardon
Vindication
DelegationDelegation refers to the act of assigning responsibility or authority to another person or group to carry out specific tasks or duties. It often involves transferring decision-making power or certain functions to others while maintaining overall accountability.Assignment Authorization Entrustment TransferRetention Concentration Withholding Centralization
DeludeDelude means to deceive or mislead someone into believing something that is not true. It involves causing someone to hold false beliefs or impressions, often by presenting incorrect or distorted information.Deceive
Mislead
Beguile
Trick
Enlighten
Inform
Clarify
Reveal
UntenableUntenable refers to a position, argument, or situation that cannot be defended, justified, or maintained, typically because it is flawed, weak, or unsustainable.Indefensible Unsustainable Unjustifiable
Weak
Defensible Sustainable  Justifiable
Tenable

Fuel your success with Edusprint! Our seasoned faculty, proven strategies, and personalized support ensure a transformative learning experience. Enroll now to conquer competitive exams and fast-track your dream job. #EdusprintSuccess

10-years-exp-in-competitive-exams-coaching-edusprint-ssc-railway-tnpsc-bank-coaching

Edusprint Academy for SSC, Railways, TNPSC, Bank Exams.

Shape Your Future with Edusprint - Igniting Careers for Success!

Discover Exclusive Course Fee Offers: Inquire Now for Special Deals!

Latest & Trending Posts

Discover more from Edusprint academy

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Inquire Now

All Inquiries will get a Demo Class & Study Materials for Free