Day: May 8, 2024

  • Editorial 8 May 2024

    Title: Plastic solution: Beyond the Global Plastics Treaty

    The Global Plastics Treaty, an ambitious initiative involving at least 175 United Nations member nations to eliminate the use of plastics, concluded its fourth round of negotiations recently. The goal is to finalise a legal document by the end of 2024 with timelines by when countries must agree to curb plastic production, eliminate its uses that create wastage, ban certain chemicals used in its production and set targets for recycling. Unfortunately, an agreement is not in sight. There is yet another round of negotiations scheduled in Busan, South Korea this November. The primary hurdles are economic. Oil producing and refining countries such as Saudi Arabia, the United States, Russia, India and Iran are reluctant about hard deadlines to eliminate plastic production. A coalition of African countries, supported by several European nations, is in favour of a year, around 2040, to ensure that a timeline for reduction is in effect. There is also disagreement on whether contentious elements in the treaty should be decided on by a vote or consensus — the latter implying that every country has a veto. India’s opinion, other than being uncomfortable with binding targets, is that a legally binding instrument to end the plastic pollution must also address “… availability, accessibility, affordability of alternatives including cost implications and specifying arrangements… for capacity building and technical assistance, technology transfer, and financial assistance”. This language — and India is not the only       — is reminiscent of the principle of ‘common but differentiated responsibility’ enshrined in climate talks. Under this, countries must have a common target but those more privileged must support others and take on stricter targets themselves.

    In the year that the plastics treaty was mooted, in 2022, India brought into effect the Plastic Waste Management Amendment Rules (2021) that banned 19 categories of “single-use” plastics. It, however, does not include plastic bottles — even those less than 200 ml — and multi-layered packaging boxes (as in milk cartons). Moreover, even the ban on single-use plastic items is not uniformly enforced nationally, with several outlets continuing to retail these goods. The global distribution of the plastic pollution is unequal with Brazil, China, India and the U.S. responsible for 60% of plastic waste, according to a report by the non-profit EA Earth Action. Much like how transitioning away from fossil fuel invites its own challenges, plastic pollution cannot be ended by merely signing treaties. There needs to be much greater investment in alternative products and making them affordable before realistic targets are decided upon.

    Meaning of the word:

    WordMeaningSynonymsAntonyms
    Ambitioustypically refers to having a strong desire and determination to achieve success, typically in one’s career, goals, or aspirations.Driven
    Determined Aspiring
    Goal-oriented Zealous
    Unambitious Content Complacent Indifferent Apathetic
    Negotiationsrefer to discussions or talks between two or more parties with the aim of reaching an agreement or resolving a dispute.Discussions
    Talks
    Dialogues Bargaining Diplomacy
    Impasse
    Standstill Disagreement Discord
    Conflict  
    Reluctantdescribes a feeling of hesitation, unwillingness, or resistance to do something. When someone is reluctant, they may feel unsure, hesitant, or unwilling to proceed with a particular action or decision.Hesitant
    Unwilling
    Resistant Disinclined
    Unsure  
    Eager
    Willing
    Enthusiastic
    Ready Keen
    Coalitionrefers to an alliance or partnership formed by individuals, groups, or organizations who come together to achieve a common goal or objective.Alliance Partnership
    Union Confederation Collaboration  
    Division
    Disunity
    Separation Disagreement Opposition
    Reminiscentdescribes something that evokes memories or feelings of the past. When something is reminiscent of a particular time, place, or experience, it bears similarities or associations with it, often bringing to mind thoughts or emotions from that earlier period.Evocative
    Redolent Suggestive Resonant Provocative  
    Forgetful Unmemorable Uninspiring Unremarkable Non-evocative
  • Editorial 7 May 2024

    Editorial 7 May 2024

    Title: Time to talk: On Tamil Nadu, Kerala and the Mullaperiyar dam row

    Tamil Nadu’s latest application in the Supreme Court of India on the Mullaperiyar dam row shows that even 10 years after the Court’s decisive judgment allowing water to be stored till 142 ft. from the previously reduced 136 ft., several issues with Kerala still remain unresolved. In a rejoinder to Kerala’s reply in a case filed by an activist, Tamil Nadu, the beneficiary-owner State, has accused Kerala, where the dam is located, of “crying foul” about the safety of the 129-year-old structure, while at the same time “wilfully obstructing” work essential for its maintenance. Despite the constitution of three panels, i.e., a Supervisory Committee (which was reconstituted by having a technical member from each State in June 2022) and two sub-committees (one of which is under the National Executive Committee of the National Disaster Management Authority) to ensure a high level of preparedness to face any disaster related to the dam, no one is any closer to finding a solution to the pending issues. Tamil Nadu’s grievance is that the reconstituted Supervisory Committee, despite having powers under the Dam Safety Act, 2021, had “miserably failed” to ensure that Kerala and its instrumentalities permit and facilitate dam strengthening and other related works. Tamil Nadu has also been pressing for the early completion of a comprehensive dam safety evaluation within five years, by December 30, 2026, as stipulated under the 2021 law.

    But despite unresolved issues, judicial intervention has seen the adoption of rule curve, a tool in decision-making for smooth operation of the dam’s shutters, especially during floods, and the gate operation schedule, notwithstanding Kerala’s reservations. Apart from the dam-related issues, the proposal of a mega car parking project of the Kerala government is a matter of litigation. The conclusion of the Survey of India that the project site is outside the leased area has been disputed by Tamil Nadu. As for Kerala, dam safety has been its primary concern and it wants to proceed cautiously. It is time that the two State governments, which enjoy good relations, resumed bilateral negotiations to find a solution to pending problems while retaining their liberty to adopt legal recourse. Courts take their own time to arrive at their conclusion, even though Tamil Nadu has a more favourable track record with the Supreme Court than the other State on Mullaperiyar, going by the 2006 and 2014 judgments. As water and dam safety can be used by some elements to arouse emotions, the political leadership in both States should be proactive in thrashing out the differences. The proposed talks, even in the event of not leading to any major breakthrough, may at least provide both States an opportunity to appreciate each other’s position better and leave no room for vested interests to vitiate the atmosphere.

    Meaning of the word:

    WordMeaningSynonymsAntonyms
    Decisiveis an adjective that describes someone or something that is able to make decisions quickly and effectively, without hesitation or uncertainty.Resolute Determined
    Firm
    Conclusive
    Definite
    Indecisive Tentative
    Unsure
    Doubtful Hesitant
    Beneficiaryis a person or entity that receives benefits, advantages, or assets from something. This term is commonly used in the context of legal documents such as wills, trusts, insurance policies, and retirement accounts.Recipient
    Heir
    Legatee
    Grantee Payee
    Donor
    Grantor
    Giver
    Contributor Payer  
    Comprehensiveis an adjective that describes something that is thorough, complete, and covers all aspects or elements of a particular subject or topic. It implies a broad and inclusive scope, leaving no important detail or aspect overlooked.Exhaustive Thorough
    Complete
    Inclusive
    All-encompassing
    Limited Incomplete Partial
    Narrow Superficial
    Litigationrefers to the process of resolving disputes or legal conflicts through the court system. It typically involves two or more parties, such as individuals, businesses, or organizations, who are involved in a disagreement and seek a resolution through the formal judicial process.Legal action
    Lawsuit Legal proceedings Judicial
    process
    Legal dispute  
    Settlement Agreement Resolution Compromise Accord
  • Editorial 6 May 2024

    Editorial 6 May 2024

    Title: In the frontline: On Rahul Gandhi contesting from Rae Bareli

    Congress leader Rahul Gandhi has entered the electoral fray in the Hindi heartland too, ending a prolonged suspense just in time to file his nomination on May 3, in Rae Bareli, Uttar Pradesh. His grandfather, grandmother, and mother were among those who represented this constituency, located around 80 km south-east of the State capital Lucknow. Mr. Gandhi had lost the adjoining Amethi constituency in 2019, even as he won Wayanad in Kerala. He is seeking re-election in Wayanad, and had to decide whether to contest at all from the Hindi heartland and, if so, whether it had to be Rae Bareli or Amethi. He chose Rae Bareli, which was won by his mother Sonia Gandhi in 2019, who is now a member of the Rajya Sabha. A family loyalist has been fielded in Amethi. Mr. Gandhi has been vocal about his liking for Wayanad, and waited for voting there before the candidacy in Rae Bareli was announced. This reeks of a scheme, perhaps unintended, but certainly avoidable. A forthright and early decision would have been more appropriate for his stature, and respectful towards the electorates. His sister, Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, who has emerged as an impactful campaigner for the Congress across the country, chose not to contest, while her husband Robert Vadra’s embarrassing public demand for the party ticket has been overlooked by the party, and rightly so.

    Mr. Gandhi has declared that resisting the BJP’s Hindutva politics and advancement of social justice are his life’s mission. That battle is being fought primarily in the Hindi belt and the western region of the country. Electorally and ideologically, the BJP derives its strength from those regions. While the BJP is focused in its efforts to expand in the south, the Congress is confused in its strategy to regain its lost glory in the Hindi States. By deciding to contest from Kerala in 2019, Mr. Gandhi made a strategic mistake of seeking refuge in a comfort zone. He had the opportunity to correct it by returning to the tough battle in U.P. this time, but he kept vacillating. Though it has been not done in the best manner, his entry could enthuse the Opposition in U.P. The Congress is in an alliance with the Samajwadi Party (SP) in U.P., and the decision of SP chief Akhilesh Yadav to contest the election from Kannauj could also help the alliance. Considering the dominance of the BJP in the Hindi belt, the Congress faces an uphill task. In the event of winning both Wayanad and Rae Bareli, Mr. Gandhi must retain the latter and make it clear that he is in the ideological war with the BJP for the longer term.

    Meaning of the word:

    WordMeaningsynonymsantonyms
    FrayVerb: To unravel or become worn at the edge, typically referring to fabric or rope. Noun: A situation or conflict marked by tension, strain, or disagreement, as in “The political fray intensified as the election approached.”Struggle
    Conflict
    Dispute
    Altercation
    Clash
    Harmony
    Peace
    Agreement
    Truce
    Accord
    Prolongedis an adjective that describes something that continues for an extended period of time, often longer than expected or usual. It implies that the duration of the activity, event, or condition is more extensive than typical or anticipated.Extended
    Lengthy
    Prolonged
    Long-lasting Continual
    Brief
    Short
    Temporary Transient
    Fleeting
    Perhapsis an adverb used to indicate uncertainty or possibility. It suggests that something is possible or may happen, but it’s not certain.Maybe
    Possibly
    Conceivably Potentially Perchance
    Definitely Certainly
    Surely
    Absolutely Without a doubt
    Heartlandtypically refers to the central or most important part of a country, region, or area.Core
    Center
    Mainland
    Hub
    Central
    region
    Periphery Outskirts
    Fringe
    Margins Borderland
    Embarrassingis an adjective used to describe a situation, action, or event that causes someone to feel awkward, self-conscious, or ashamed.Awkward Uncomfortable Humiliating Mortifying DiscomfitingProud
    Confident Comfortable Unashamed Triumphant
    gloryis a noun that refers to great honor, praise, or admiration bestowed upon someone or something.Fame
    Honor
    Splendor
    Grandeur Prestige
    Shame
    Disgrace Obscurity Ignominy
    Infamy
  • Editorial 3 May 2024

    Editorial 3 May 2024

    Title: Eastern front: On the electoral battle in West Bengal  

    The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) nurtures high hopes in West Bengal, where it won 18 of the 42 seats, and 40% vote share in 2019. This dramatic rise from two seats in 2014 gave the party the confidence to present itself as the principal opposition in the 2021 Assembly polls, but the Mamata Banerjee-led All India Trinamool Congress (TMC) stormed back to power for a third term. With 77 of the 294 Assembly seats, and a 38.1% vote share, the BJP came a distant second. This year, the polling in the State is spread across all seven phases of the general election, and the BJP is pulling out all stops in the hope it could improve its tally which could also compensate for any electoral loss elsewhere. The BJP is keeping the TMC on the defensivewith allegations of corruption, the land grab and sexual assault at Sandeshkhali, and the school recruitment scam. The Calcutta High Court terminated about 25,000 teacher appointments which is a shot in the arm for the BJP. The TMC’s campaign against the BJP is centred on New Delhi’s stoppage of funds to the State under central schemes and the Citizenship (Amendment) Act. It is also banking on its cash transfer schemes such as Lakshmir Bhandar for women. Highlighting the issue of women’s safety, the BJP has fielded a woman from Sandeshkhali, the constituency that saw reports of assault on women.

    The BJP hopes to perform better in the districts of north Bengal, where it had won seven out of eight seats in 2019, while the Trinamool’s focus is more in the southern districts with a high proportion of Muslim voters. For this, the TMC is also battling the Left-Congress coalition. The alliance may turn out to be a factor in certain seats in the minority-dominated districts of Malda and Murshidabad, and the decision of the Indian Secular Front to walk out of the alliance is likely to work to the advantage of the TMC. The BJP is bringing up Ram Mandir, violence during Ram Navami processions and the illegal movement of people across the India-Bangladesh border. Polarisation of voters on religious lines had helped the BJP in the 2019 Lok Sabha election and the Trinamool in the 2021 Assembly polls, edging out the Left and Congress from the field. The Trinamool is also harping on the Bengali identity by presenting itself as its custodian and portraying the BJP as an interloper and being insensitive to the interests of the State. For the BJP, West Bengal is not merely about winning more seats but is also about expanding its foothold into a region that claims exceptionalism. Some of the earliest arguments for a Hindu polity had originated in Bengal, and this gives the BJP hope.

    Meaning of the word

    WordMeaningsynonymsantonyms
    Compensategive (someone) something, typically money, in recognition of loss, suffering, or injury incurred; recompense.Reimburse Remunerate Indemnify
    Repay Offset  
    Deprive
    Withhold
    Penalize
    Punish
    Forfeit  
    Allegationsa claim or assertion that someone has done something illegal or wrong, typically one made without proofAccusations
    Charges
    Claims Assertions Accusations  
    Acquittal
    Exoneration Vindication
    Validation Confirmation  
    Coalitiona temporary alliance for combined action, especially of political parties forming a government.Alliance
    Union
    Partnership Confederation Federation  
    Dissolution
    Disunion
    Division
    Separation Disassociation  
    Harpingtypically refers to persistently and repetitively talking or complaining about the same issue or topic, often in a critical or complaining manner.Nagging
    Repeating
    Dwelling
    Persisting Obsessing  
    Letting go
    Moving on Forgetting
    Ignoring
    Dismissing  
    Interloperrefers to someone who intrudes or intervenes in a situation where they are not wanted or invited.Intruder
    Trespasser
    Meddler
    Intrusion
    Meddler  
    Insider
    Participant Inhabitant
    Resident Member